
In a world increasingly shaped by artificial intelligence and a relentless culture of speed, a pertinent question arises for creatives: Is craftsmanship dying? According to Jonny Tan, a seasoned creative director with a career spanning continents and groundbreaking campaigns, the answer is nuanced, but the concerns are palpable.
"The advent of new technology and new possibilities… It's like a person sort of games and you collect tools," Johnny observes, drawing a vivid analogy. "And when the more tools you collect, the toys you have, the weapons you have, it's like the more badass you become." This abundance of "bazookas and whatnot" at a creative's disposal, while empowering, also presents a curious paradox. It makes us "less reliant on the pure craft of solving a problem," he warns.
The Vanishing Act of Hand-Drawn Art
Johnny, who has witnessed the creative industry's seismic shifts firsthand, highlights a disturbing trend: the vanishing of hand-drawn storyboards. "In the last year or so, I haven't seen a hand-drawn storyboard," he laments. Instead, everything is "crafted because somebody wrote a prompt and it came out. It was beautiful." While acknowledging the undeniable power of AI to "level up the game," Johnny believes it simultaneously strips away "finer things of creativity."
The "Blur" of Accelerated Creativity
His concern isn't about shunning AI entirely. He’s a "big fan of what AI could do," but he worries about the accelerated pace leading to a "blur" in the creative process. Filmmakers, for instance, traditionally consider every detail – camera movements, cuts, the subtle nuances of a close-up versus a wide shot. He recalls a timeless piece of advice from Steven Spielberg: "You want to learn how to make a film, watch movies and turn the volume off." This exercise forces an understanding of the deliberate choices made in crafting a visual narrative. With AI-generated content, Johnny suggests, these crucial considerations often take a backseat.
The Tactile Core of True Craftsmanship
"Craftsmanship has a combination of things," he explains. "Both a very visceral thing and at the same time it's also a very tactile thing." This vital combination, he believes, is what makes something truly special. AI, by its very nature, might accelerate production, but in doing so, it risks losing the “magic of craft.”
Over-Reliance vs. True Innovation
The core of the issue, Johnny argues, isn't the tool itself, but an over-reliance on its convenience. Just as a soldier relying solely on GPS might lose the ability to navigate independently, creatives empowered by AI might forgo the fundamental understanding of their art. AI can certainly provide a push, an initial spark when faced with the daunting "white piece of paper." However, he cautions against the temptation to let it become the sole solution.
The Enduring Value of Human Voice and Vision
For Johnny, the fundamental tools a creative must possess remain constant: "the ability to find a compelling original solution and an effective one." While AI can aid in achieving that, it's crucial not to lose sight of the human element. Curation, for example, becomes paramount. If everyone uses the same tools, the inevitable outcome is a sea of "vanilla" products. It's the unique point of view, the individual taste, and the distinct vision that elevate a piece of work from good to truly great.
Preserving the Magic
"I still don't know how that would look," Johnny admits regarding a future where this trend continues. But he is certain of one thing: "I certainly don't think that's going to be a great future." The vibrant tapestry of human creativity, with its imperfections, its struggles, and its triumphs of dedicated craftsmanship, is too precious to lose to the allure of instant gratification. The future of art, it seems, hinges on creatives remembering that while AI can be a powerful co-pilot, the human hand must always remain on the steering wheel.
This discussion only scratches the surface of the fascinating insights Jonny Tan shares on creativity, reinvention, and leadership. To hear more of his powerful stories and bold ideas, be sure to watch and listen to the full episode of Offscript, part of the Wild & Wise Podcast.
Hosted by Gerald Ang, Ben I., and Vincent Teo, Offscript is a space where creative business minds come to explore how to stay sharp, relevant, and future-ready in a world that keeps changing. Whether you’re a founder, team leader, freelancer, or curious thinker, you’ll gain valuable insights into how to stay adaptable, purposeful, and inspired in fast-changing times.
Be Wild & Wise Today
Are you ready to unlock your strengths and achieve personal or professional growth? Whether you need help with personal branding, team alignment, or strengths-based coaching, Wild & Wise is here to guide you. Book your free consultation and take the first step towards your transformation.
Subscribe to our newsletter
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique.